MUBI'de daha iyi deneyim için tarayıcını güncelle
Critics reviews
The Image Book
Jean-Luc Godard France, 2018
A head-scratcher and a mind-bender, The Image Book . . . is gloriously obscure and brutally unpretty, yet lucid and even gorgeous all the same.
January 26, 2019
Read full article
A work of such stabbing angularity, exorbitant allusiveness, unyielding digression, and exhausting doom that the film’s sole justification, the thing that joins and stabilizes all the rattling fragments, is the totemic allure of a name: Godard.
January 25, 2019
Read full article
A work of vast visual inventiveness; it’s almost entirely made up of images that are so elaborately and personally crafted that they seem handmade, like cine-paintings. But the images are onscreen so briefly, and edited together so boldly and so surprisingly, as to suggest that the film is meant to be used, perused, and pondered, privately and slowly, bit by bit, like a book.
January 25, 2019
Read full article
Caveats aside, this is, in my estimation, a typically stimulating but opaque and deliberately frustrating late-period Godard film.
January 25, 2019
Read full article
As Godard’s montage moves from culture to culture, through different eras of reportage and make-believe, The Image Book considers nothing less than the irony of classical art in competition with political reality. It’s a poetic analysis that achieves its power through metaphor and allusion, linking not-random images to specific mythic resonance.
January 25, 2019
Read full article
I found it haunting, thrilling and confounding in equal measure. It is a work of ecstatic despair, an argument for the futility of human effort that almost refutes itself through the application of a grumpy and tenacious artistic will.
January 23, 2019
Read full article
The Image Book is a new step for Godard, a foray into a world decentered from its European ground. It is a provisional film, feeling its way and testing analytic and aesthetic categories. It doesn’t always succeed, but it has the sense of a beginning, and that gives hope that it is the start of something new.
January 02, 2019
Manipulation . . . is everywhere, closely allied with the operations of the digital, from the Latin digitus, ‘finger’ or ‘toe’. And through it all, to the end, when Godard coughs his way through proclaiming the need for “ardent hope” in the face of the “strongest nights”, The Image Book contemplates what possibilities of salvation and beauty might still reside in our horrific and uncertain world.
December 06, 2018
Read full article
There may be logic to the constant barrage of text, sound and image, but it is very much in the eye of the beholder. What this film does is make it feel exciting to look, listen and feel.
December 03, 2018
Read full article
Just as Goodbye to Language acknowledged—no, embodied—our inability to function without the structures (symbolic, semiotic) and hierarchies (ideological, cultural) that make up our specific existence and which come part and parcel with language, The Image Book does so with a visual lexicon of which cinema is but a part.
October 10, 2018
Read full article
If cinema, for all its polysemous potential to complicate the fateful, scriptural marriage of word and image, offered a kind of Plan B, but also ultimately failed to subvert (or liberate us from) the fixed subject-object representation whereby power is reiterated and reproduced, this is why Godard turns (again) to the Brechtian “fragment” as a last refuge of that malleable, polysemous potential.
October 08, 2018
Read full article
While even loyalists may find “The Image Book” sometimes rough going, it is a fascinating object, partly because Mr. Godard, now 87, seems to be sifting through a lifetime of images and ideas (on war and more war) amid shocks of beauty and horror.
October 03, 2018
Read full article
At 87, Godard is still with us and, amazingly enough, still cranking out films that bristle with energy and inventiveness. Though I wouldn’t place it as among his very best, “The Image Book” struck me as a more agreeable and engaging feature than his last few.
September 29, 2018
Read full article
Godard weds and wrests images, text, and music into a thrilling, gnomic salvo, returning to the protracted three-decade late style of his magnum opus, Histoire(s) du cinéma (1988-98).
September 07, 2018
Read full article
Of all the feature-length movies Godard has made since Histoire(s), this is the most abstract, in the sense that only the last of its five sections has anything like a narrative. Godard has used almost all of these images in other collage films, but here they are even more fragmented, transformed with variable speeds, colorization, and other digital processes.
July 03, 2018
Read full article
It’s been fascinating to watch him try to arrive at some kind of endpoint where the film itself, his ongoing work, his relation to the art of cinema, and the impending end of his own existence will somehow converge. . . . To see Le Livre d’image at the Cannes Film Festival as it is now was a moving experience, like a signal from a now distant moment.
July 03, 2018
Read full article
A work of montage, a dynamic assembly of images and sounds, whether created by Godard’s own hand or plucked from humanity’s audiovisual reservoirs. And the principles governing this montage-practice are primarily tactile in nature: it is the feel of an image, the feel of a sound, that governs Godard’s hand on the (virtual) editing table, more so than any explicit meaning or intentionality.
June 27, 2018
Read full article
Title notwithstanding, sound is at least as important as image: Voice-of-Godard musings and snatches of film dialogue encircle the viewer in ricocheting surround sound, which Godard deploys for maximum disorientation, much as he did 3-D in Goodbye to Language (2014).
May 29, 2018
Read full article
For all my initial bafflement, The Image Book continued to haunt me. Maybe that’s all Godard wanted. Throughout the festival, in conversation, I found myself going over and over his editing strategies. . . . It felt as if, true to his title, Godard was creating a compendium of images, an encyclopedia of visual references for the Western mind.
May 24, 2018
Read full article
Disjointed and direct, exhilarating and soporific, cerebral and squirrelly: The Image Bookis lots of contradictory things at once. And if it’s hard to understand exactly what Godard is trying to say in this brief scrapbook scamper—it clocks in at one hour, 25 minutes—just watching it is a strange, melancholy pleasure, and an open window into the world of things that worry its creator.
May 14, 2018
Read full article
Undoubtedly the most experimental feature ever shown in Cannes competition . . . The Image Book feels like notes from the underground, a bunker film, trying to assemble and learn from the moving image remnants of humankind in the 20th and 21st century.
May 13, 2018
Read full article
It’s through exercising a certain kind of madness—the demented way that Godard asserts his own presence in The Image Book—that the film connects even at its most disjointed.
May 13, 2018
Read full article
Essentially, we are thrust into what is designed to feel like chaos, and the act of watching The Image Book feels like a process of categorization, of putting words and images into cognitive compartments so that the sensual can translate into sense.
May 12, 2018
Read full article
The Image Book if nothing else, is inestimable, in that it defies normal estimation or assessment; to encounter a film this intransigently confrontational by an artist who shows no sign of softening will be a nightmare for many, but yes, for many a privilege and a pleasure.
May 11, 2018
Read full article