For a better experience on MUBI, update your browser.

Rafael Fonseca's rating of the film American Horror Story: Coven

Ryan Murphy & Co. IS one of the most idiosyncratic voices on television yes, but this is far from the relative lighting-in-a-bottle that was his season 1 (Murder House) or to an extent, Asylum. If not for the acting (Jessica Lange and Kathy Bates are superstars) it would be unwatchable. Script is straight convoluted, backtracking, retconning, uninteresting, plain bad - it just gets more and more stupid.